Hey everyone, my name is Anthony and welcome back to my Movie Review.
Back in 2023, I covered Five Nights at Freddy’s movie, which, after all these years of waiting and “won’t they won’t they”, its definitely about time to what we have, while the critics are rather… Nitpicky on this movie, but it didn’t matter for the general audience (mainly FNAF fans) love this movie and of course, it made a LOTTA money at the box-office. As for me, I did see a potential that I was hoping this could be a fairly decent film, but alas, despite it has a few redeeming quality and some presentations that il give credit, but everything else is a complete letdown that I left a lot of question in my disappointment. And yet, despite the success, its no stranger that both Blumhouse Productions and FNAF creator, Scott Cawthon work together again to make a sequel in today’s review.
“Five Nights at Freddy’s 2” is a 2025 supernatural horror movie based video game that was directed by Emma Tammi, written/produced by Scott Cawthon (yup, the creator FNAF franchise) and co-produced by Jason Blum.
While they were in long development hell before the official release of the first FNAF movie, the creator of FNAF, Scott Cawthon was told that if the movie is a success, there will be a sequel, which his honesty is predicted that when the first one came out, again, it made a lot of money, so its no surprising that the sequel were planned. Supposedly, if you’re familiar with the games, FNAF2 isn’t really a sequel, but rather a prequel from the first game, whereas the second one took place in the 80s, while the first one takes place in the 90s, which is exactly what we hoped for when Scott mentioned that the sequel follows the event of his game, despite in the middle of the writing, it required between 4 to 5 drafts while the first one had 14 drafts (Jesus, Scott, over complicated for the draft much??). Though even if I was curiously if they show us the trailer for the sequel, but after saw it, it feels more like a sequel than a prequel.
Normally, I wanna do a Movie Review after I watch a movie in the theater, but it would’ve been fine if this one comes out on November, rather than December (due to busy celebrating Christmas). But the craziest part is three weeks after it came out on the big screen, they immediately released the movie in digital market, which I eventually bought it a week ago before New Year.
So, with all that said, will this movie can get better than the first one, or is this film should be abandoned and withered?
Well, lets find out.
The Story
Though I might do the comparison between the movie and the game, mainly I’ve seen couple of videos about the complicated lore and even the setting. BUT, you think the story could be like a prequel as I mentioned before? Well, not really, it goes into follow-up story, but good lord… Where the hell am I begin…?!
Okay, so the movie begins in the flashback of 1982 where we had the very first Freddy Fazbear’s Pizza, where it used to be not just decorative, but also a fascinating place with boat river ride, marry-go-round and couple other fun stuff, however, one child named Charlotte Emily has witnessed a boy being lured by SpringBonnie (SPOILER ALERT, he’s actually William Afton in a bunny animatronic suit, the owner of the pizzeria and child murderer) that she had to going in the back rooms to rescue the boy, but despite her best effort to save him, she was startled by SpringBonnie for a chase and backstabbed her to death and collapsed on the trap door to death in front of the guests (including Vanessa Shelly, who happens to be Will’s long lost daughter, if anyone who haven’t seen the first FNAF movie), with dead Charlotte lays on The Marionette's arms, causing the restaurant being permanently shutdown and the murder was blamed to Charlotte’s family for un-checking her before she was killed, right before we have the rebooted Freddy Fazbear’s Pizza and of coursed, five more kids being “disappeared” to death (im sure you already know that, right?). Fast Forward to 2002, where Vanessa is living on her own (while still as local police officer) in attempt to going back to normal, despite having a nightmare from her childhood memory. Meanwhile, Mike Schmidt is retired from security guard to keeping his young sister Abby to be back to normal too, but alas, Abby really missed her “friends, aka the OG animatronics. After desperately going back to the abandoned pizzeria with unable to receive the respond from the OG animatronics, Abby and Mike discovered a talking toy called “FazTalker”. But little did Abby knows, FazTalker possesses to talking to her to come to the very first pizzeria, which is nothing but a red flag from insecure warning about the possession from Marionette, which its up to Mike and Vanessa to stop before the nightmare is coming back.
Yeah, despite its meant to be FNAF2, but this movie just completely messed up the plot from the get-go with all the subplots and plothole that left myself with so many baffling questions. One of which is where we introduced ghost hunters called “Spectral Scoopers” (subtle…) that they’re the first group who broke into the first pizzeria and met Michael Afton. Does these guys have to do with the plot? NOTHING! They’re just group of idiots for being the bodycounts, while Michael is watching them to suffer, let along one of the group being possessed by Marionette, I mean, I get its meant to be a built up for the second act, but its just dumb way to introduced the first abandoned Freddy Fazbear’s Pizza. Not to mention, the movie also feels like we’re going backward that all because Abby missed the animatronics, she left herself to meet the Toy Animatronics, despite she didn’t even recognized them (unless if its the similar possession from five dead children, that’s just my guess), she just weirdly befriend with Toy Animatronics and break them free without warning and causing trouble, like does it nearly sounds like the first film, don’t ya?? And not to mention, the movie also have a subplot about the horror themed festival called “FazFest”, just because some people are weirdly fascinated about the legend of the murders, which again, it would be a bad idea for exploitation, and again, does this festival have to do with the plot? “NOTHING! Absolutely Nothing!”. Jesus, this movie has a mishmash of subplot and fillers left to nothing (for the most part), along with plothole that left us as “is there anywhere to stop Marionette other than music box?”, “Where Michael have been after the ghost hunters?!”, or even “Is this make any sense to bring Toy animatronics free!?”. So many unanswered questions that left myself into frustration for what kind of stupid writing was that?? And don’t even get me started on the final act, because… You don’t want to know from SPOILER, it is just so stupid to explain…! I mean sure, the movie does trying to replicate from the game like wearing animatronic mask or even being distracted by the dreaded Balloon Boy with Withered Animatronics, but that was is just a tease… Like, im just disappointed that they couldn’t replace almost everything from FNAF2 the game, especially didn’t even brought the game’s protagonist Jeremy Fitzgerald.
The writing and the story are a convoluted mess that it just completely missed the plot with so many messy plotholes, subplots and fillers that left myself so many questions and frustations in left and right…!
The Presentation
While the writing and the direction are a broken down mess, but what about the presentation, you asked? Well, the movie’s budget costs between $36M to $51M, possibly doubled than the first film’s budget. And despite the flaws, it has a few redeeming quality that il give some credit.
For starter, the filming is actually look pretty nice, sure it still looks like a low budget film for how it looks, but still, it looks fairly decent from the school of science fair, the small town to pizzerias. Yes for the latter, it seems that we have a brief moment to going back at the first film’s pizzeria, though its for small plot device before we’re going to the one that started it all before the one from the first movie. Speaking of which, what about the first Freddy Fazbear’s Pizza? At first for the outdoor, it may sounds like odd with trees growing behind the pizzeria, I mean yes, since its been abandoned, its been overground by nature, which im pretty sure this place being listed as part of “forbidden area” due to dark history of Charlotte’s death. As for the indoor, its a pretty nice spot that it has arcade and marry-go-around, but it also has a river boat ride, which il give credit to be something creative, though perhaps could’ve add a bit more colors in the interior, maybe flashy and colorful, though not as glamorous as FNAF: Security Breach, but that’s just my complaint.
But I think the biggest highlight and the focus of the budget is, without a doubt, are the animatronics. Like the first game, the animatronics are pretty much played by the people in animatronic costumes to do slow and stiff movement and for their presentation, once again, they look pretty good and faithful from the game that we all know, which im pretty sure this is what Scott wanted, the animatronics looks not only the same, but faithful from the game, ranging from the Toy Animatronics to the old prototypes known as Withered Animatronics, they’re ranging from the aforementioned people in costumes, the animatronic heads and some are fully down in animatronic effects like some of Withered ones, the annoying Balloon Boy, and even Mangle (who’s meant to be Toy Foxy, but abandoned). But then there are other times some were done with few CG, like that im easily assuming is the scene where Mangle is clinging the roof of the car. Like the first movie, the animatronic costumes and some animatronics were done by Jim Henson's Creature Shop, so shout out for these guys for coming back for more. However, when it comes to Marionette, while it looks accurate from the game, but I find it rather odd for being portrayed as a puppet dangling around and possessing humans on her way, I like the design, but as a vengeful possessive ghost? Not so much. Although, im also surprise it also including Easter Eggs that we all know, but I won’t give details from SPOILERS, maybe its just a setup for future movie installments, but again, that’s just me.
Now, since this is the horror, you think we wanna get to see something terrifying and some brutal kills in the movie? Well guess what? Not only its PG-13 like before, but this movie is suffered with the weakest kills I’ve ever seen. Such as the Spectral Scoopers are the only ones get a bodycount, but alas, they’re only in off-screen kills like one of them is simply drowned by those Marionette models from the river ride, which the incoming splash looks like something out of Amnesia the game or one of then gets caught by Mangle. But the only one that I like is where Toy Chica crushes Mr. Berg’s head, again, its ruined by off-screen, but I can’t help find it referenced from Friday the 13th Part 3 and/or Part 6 where Jason crushes victim’s head (stay tune on February with actual Friday the 13th that il review Part 6). Despite one okay kill, but im disappointed that it has less bodycount compared the first game, not because its rated PG-13, but its just the kills are forgettable, it focuses too much on Animatronics coming out around and some cheap jumpscares. And yes, the jumpscares are unfortunately predictable that I was easily guessing that it didn’t scare me at all (maybe im too old school, but again, predictable).
While the filming locations, the setting, one of the kills, some Easter Eggs and the animatronics are the best parts of the presentation, but its just flawed from the depiction of Marionette and the less and worst kills.
The Characters
While the writing and the direction are bad, you think the characters will make a new developments for sequel, right? None… 90% of them have no developments… For the most part…
Lets start off with Mike Schmidt (reprised by Josh Hutcherson, aka Peeta from The Hunger Game) the main protagonist of the movies who started out as a loser to now a protective to his sister. And… That’s pretty much it, he’s just a protective big brother while potentially going on relationship with Vanessa, it feels like he has a small development from the first movie, but now he’s an underdeveloped protag that it feels like we completely forgot about him. Im not saying im bashing on Josh, I think his performance is fine, but its just that im easily blame the writing that he’s been treated like an afterthought, otherwise, again, it just makes you wish if this movie has Jeremy Fitzgerald much like in the game, but here, Mike is our main hero, and yet he’s still forgettable for how he was badly written.
Next, we have Vanessa Shelly (reprised by Elizabeth Lail), the local police officer, William Afton’s daughter and the possibly love interest to Mike. Vanessa is the closest one to having her own character development, mainly she has a mental scar from her childhood memory from what happened back in the very first Freddy Fazbear’s Pizza where Charlotte was killed by her father as SpringBonnie, which it will be a good thing that she’s gotta overcome her trauma against the animatronics (both Toy and Withered). But alas, despite she’s gotta fight her traumatic past, but it seems that we nearly forgot about her, like one moment where she’s hold in hostage by possessed victim from Marionette, and especially she could’ve kept being the character with plot details how or why just happened. But here, she has a slightly upgrade on her role and… That’s pretty much it, despite she’s the closest character development she has after what happened. Though like Josh, I’ve nothing against Elizabeth, she did a nice work of her role, but the writing could’ve gone better.
And lastly we have Abby Schmidt (reprised by Piper Rubio), she’s Mike’s younger brother and the becoming a student of science fair, despite her animatronic friends are pretty much stuck in her mind instead of accepting the fate and moving on. But alas, despite she’s gotta be prepare to be in school, she’s been treated as an outsider, all because she cares in her mind is interacting with animatronics, but when again, she meets the Toy Animatronics, she could’ve learned that they’re completely different compared to the previous animatronics she met back then…! Yeah, I find her to be annoying and unable to change her mind to be back to normal, especially acknowledging the dark history about Freddy Fazbear’s Pizza. Much like her big brother Mike, she’s pretty much in downgrade, for the most part. Again, im not saying I hate her, I mean, like before Piper did a fairly decent performance, but again, just blame the way she was written.
As for the new ones, they’re pretty much a waste of space that we just wish some new characters could’ve make more appearance, or maybe they’re just there to be killed, We have Michael Afton (played by Freddy Carter) is a the new security guard of the first pizzeria, despite he’s meant to be the main antagonist, but he barely make any appearances in the movie, Mr. Berg (played by Wayne Knight, aka Stan Podolak from Space Jam) who’s a teacher of the school who possibly mistreating his students, Henry Emily (played by Skeet Ulrich) who’s the father of the late Charlotte, Jeremiah (played by Theodus Crane) who’s Mike’s co-worker and Spectral Scoopers, Alex, Lisa and Rob (played by Teo Briones, Mckenna Grace and David Andrew Calvillo) the paranormal hunters that they’re just there for bodycounts.
One thing that im surprised are the Toy Animatronics. Unlike the previous or Withered ones, the Toy Animatronics got their own spoken dialogue in the movie, such as Toy Freddy is voiced by Kellen Goff, Toy Chica is voiced by Megan Fox (not bad, even though im not a fan of her) and, in big surprised, Toy Bonnie is voiced by none other than former Game Theorist, Matthew Patrick, aka MatPat. Its quite amazing for the latter that he came back for the second time after been in cameo role in the first movie. Speaking of cameo, CoryxKenshin made returning cameo as a taxi driver.
Oh, and as for William Afton/SpringBonnie (reprised by Matthew Lillard), well… He’s only made in cameo from the flashback… yay...
While the actors did nice work of their performance and nice inclusion of voices of Toy Animatronics, but these characters are either downgraded or even lackluster due to, again, very bad writing.
And now for my final opinion of this film
Overall, Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 is not only the worst, but also the most disappointing sequel I’ve ever seen…!
This movie is suffered with broken down writing, mismanaged direction, non-existent story, downgraded characters and it has the weakest kills in the movie, this is nothing but a big pile a disappointing turd film that I was expecting to be promising, but they just completely fell apart like being tripped by shoe laces…!
I mean sure, there are a few redeeming qualities that il give credit what they’re trying with nice filming, pretty good setting in the very first pizzeria, some good acting and of course, pretty good and accurate animatronic designs, but again, neither of them couldn’t save themselves from this mess.
Even though this isn’t the absolute WORST movie of the year that I’ve ever seen, but in defense, its not as extremely bad as either Happy Gilmore 2 or the godawful War of the Worlds 2025. I think its safe to say that its only for die-hard fans of FNAF, but for none fans or former fans like me, just don’t even bother to watching this, its a complete letdown for what would’ve been… Absolute disappointment…!
For my rating, im gonna give this one a 2.5/10, along with earning the Dumpster Fire of FAILURE.
So this ends of my Movie Review, if you guys have your opinion or any suggestions, let me know at comment bellow and support me on KO-FI.com/blackevil.
Thanks for reading, and im Anthony, signing out.






